Sunday, December 12, 2010

Advertising in the 1920's

Being an English communications major with a concentration in advertising, I was always intrigued by trends in the advertising world. I also found myself struggling with many ethical questions attached to a career in advertising. Upon hearing my area of study, many will respond, “You know all advertising is immoral. I hope you’re ready to lie for a career, because that’s pretty much what you’re going to be doing.” Lets just say these encounters are usually a little awkward, ending with me smiling politely (or at least trying to) while quickly scanning the premises for the nearest exit.

Being constantly questioned about my career choice, I began to wonder, how did American culture become a place where consumerism is rampant and advertising is a five hundred billion dollar industry?

Although the concept of advertising has pretty much always existed in some form or another, during the course of this class, I learned that modern advertising found its roots in the early 19th and 20th centuries, developing with the rise of mass production. The “wild, tumultuous era”, as it is described in Only Yesterday, of the roaring twenties necessitated a new kind of advertising that reflected an era permeated with the values of pleasure seeking, frivolity and obsession with youth.

In the 1920’s, society tended to “baby” adults. The use of cartoons to communicate, the “faddishness” of the popular songs of the era, society’s obsession with youth, women’s girlish desire to have flat chests and men’s boyish desire to be obsessive about sports, all contributed to the infantilization of American consumerism, a recurring theme in 1920’s advertisements.

In order for any advertisement to be successful, it must reflect the values of the time. An example of one such product whose 1920’s advertising campaign reflected a shift in societal values, is Coca-Cola. Coca Cola’s ability to identify important changes in the wants and needs of society has made it one of the largest and most visible companies in the world. When first introduced in the 1880’s, the product was marketed as having medicinal qualities, beneficial to a person’s general health and well-being. In the 1880’s, this kind of advertisement sold. In the 1920’s, not so much.

In a time of excess, people wanted excess. The American people weren’t interested in a drink that kept them healthy; they were interested in a drink they could enjoy. Seeking to please the consumers, Coca-Cola changed its technique in the 20’s, marketing the drink as a “refreshment” (as it is still known to be today) and a “fun food.”

The advertisements and mass consumer culture of the 1920’s reflected a shift in values, such as a strong emphasis on personal pleasure, leisure activities and entertainment, that remain central themes in American society even today.

How do today’s advertisements differ from those of the 1920’s? What do you think the trends in advertising are today? What modern societal values are reflected in the advertising of today? Do advertisements create the values of a generation or do societal values influence the advertisements? If you ask me, maybe it's a little bit of both.

10 comments:

  1. Avital - I loved your post!! As a fellow Communications Major, focus in Public Relations though, advertising plays a big part in how a product is presented to the general public and the press. Often, advertisements are extravagant displays of perfection. The perfect product, the perfect body, the perfect “thing you need so badly”. What many people fail to realize is the use of editing in advertising. This idea of perfection, one that, I agree, heavily influences American society, has been created by the advertising industry. What I mean by this is that often, pictures of models, or the rich and famous, are taken and later retouched to changed the appearance of the photographed person. Usually this change is to make them appear taller, thinner, prettier ect, but all to present this idea of perfection. If you haven’t seen it already, check out the Dove evolution short film (link below) that shows (better than I can describe) a little known side of the advertising industry.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iYhCn0jf46U

    ReplyDelete
  2. Avital- Firstly, I agree with you that the advertising industry is both based on, as well as shapes, society's values. Secondly, I think Tami's reference to the Dove commercial is an interesting example of advertising. While Dove is exposing the "fakeness" of advertising in a sense they are also feeding off of societal values. As in, they are purposefully defying the idea of perfection in order to generate publicity. Thus, they are still using society's obsession with perfection to their advantage, just in the opposite way.Not sure if I expressed this well let me know if you get what I am saying-

    ReplyDelete
  3. Avital, to answer your question about how the advertising industry has changed since the 20s, I think on the one that they still cater to that societal "ideal." In the 20s women's ads promoted the boyish flat-chested ideal now probably a more feminine but toned and tanned ideal. But even though I just mentioned one modern-day ideal, I think today's advertisements are aimed at many different target markets and therefore promote many different ideals (But still ideals). Maybe ads still assume people want to be something they're not but there are just more somethings to choose from nowadays..

    ReplyDelete
  4. I agree with Kim. In today's highly "personalized" age, different products target different populations. The Sketchers Tone-Ups (or whatever they're called...the funny-looking sneakers) are marketed to the "health-nut" type of American, while at the same time, Snickers and Twix bars are being advertised as fun snacks. It truly depends on the group that a company wants to target.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Tami- I love that you referenced the Dove Evolution video, it was shown at The Yeshiva University Student Medical Ethics Society Conference on mental health in October. This idea of "beauty" provides more incentive for someone to buy the product. If the same product was advertised with the model before she was "touched up", the product would probably not have sold as much. In the 1920's advertisements weren't as sexy as they are now. For instance this French Fashion ad: http://www.adclassix.com/ads/28bonmarche.htm
    compared to Abercrombie and Fitch ads of today. Both are to sell clothing however, one advertises with the actual clothing while the other uses sex appeal. This shows how advertising has changed over the years.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I agree with Tami and Jenny. Society today is obsessed with perfection and what they define as perfection is a young person in their twenties completely in shape without an ounce of fat. For men its pure muscle (but not too much just enough to be toned) and for women its just plain skinny.This is why eating disorders and plastic surgery is so popular in America. However what society fails to realize is that it is impossible to reach to perfection so instead of being happy with what they have, they will never be happy or satisfied. Also i believe that ADs play on a secret desire that most people have and publicize it which in turn will make people act on it.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Love your post before I start reading responses. I think advertising is a very smart and difficult field because as you showed, companies need to constantly change and adjust to their times and generations they are geared towards.
    I actually think our ads of today are somewhat similar in the sense that we still like to buy pretty things but in some ways we've become all about green and saving, since the recession. I love the Dove ad you bring up Tami, I think more and more, slowly but surely, companies are bringing in more "real" ideas and advertisement. Our generation is smarter than any other, we are in school earlier and longer than ever before, so the advertising industry does need to keep up with that. I look at an ad and I can tell if it's been photo shopped, and others can see that better than me!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Advertisements are there to sell products. Some of them might not be the most appropriate but they are trying to grab the majority of the population and they do whatever it takes to get people to buy their product. The one thing advertisers have to be careful of is portraying girls of being "too thin". this can lead to negative body image which is not a good thing, especially for girls.

    ReplyDelete
  9. You're right, Miriam. The body image problem as it relates to the way women are portrayed in advertisements is a rampant issue that is severely underestimated and overlooked. Speaking as women in our young 20s, even for the most intellectual and clear-minded among us, the advertisement business's "perfect woman" model infiltrates the psyche. Though I consider myself a thinking person and I conceptually understand that people are not supposed to look like THAT, a few years ago I realized that, subconsciously, if I was asked to picture what I thought of as "woman," the image that came to mind was a tall, skinny supermodel with smokey eyes and shiny, flowing hair. What a strange realization to come to! And I thought I had beat the system... If those images are powerful enough to effect those of us who realize how ridiculous they are, think about how powerful they are on the imaginations of teenage girls who idolize and admire these figures.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I vote we go back to old school advertisements where the actual product is being advertised not sex appeal. why does everything have to be so sexed up nowadays? whats wrong with being plain old pretty? why does everyone have to be drop dead gorgeous?

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.